My request for Shadrack Sibiya’s bail appeal file put Gauteng High Courts’ open justice directive to the test. A separate encounter with court staff showed me how cash can move a request up the queue.
When I sought a court file available only on Court Online, court staff described a cash payment that would move the request up the queue. They called it a “motivation fee”. They said there was nothing illegal or corrupt about it. In their telling, it was payment for faster service, something akin to a public-private partnership.
That encounter concerned a separate file. It was on my mind when I asked the Office of the Chief Justice (OCJ) for access to the bail appeal file of former deputy national police commissioner Shadrack Sibiya.
In South Africa’s constitutional democracy, open justice allows the public to see how courts exercise their power. In a bail appeal, access to the record helps a reporter explain what the appellant is challenging and, when judgment is given, how the court reached its decision. The Constitutional Court has held that openness is the ordinary starting point for court proceedings and court records.
See Constitutional Court judgment, para. 54
In City of Cape Town v SANRAL [2015] ZASCA 58, decided on 30 March 2015, the Supreme Court of Appeal rejected a blanket restriction on access to papers in a pending review of a toll-road decision. Appeal Court Judge Nathan Ponnan held that court records are public by default and that any departure must be justified. Access to the papers, he explained, lets the public and the media understand the issues and assess the court’s findings. Blanket secrecy undermines the legitimacy of the courts.
Dario Milo, an expert media lawyer at Webber Wentzel attorneys, says that, “while the law is now well established – court proceedings and filed court documents must be accessible to the public – it is important that in practice, these rights are given full effect. This means for instance that journalists should be given access to electronic databases such as Caselines and CourtOnline without delay. Access unduly delayed is access denied.”
See SANRAL Supreme Court of Appeal judgment, paras. 44–48
A week of emails
On 5 November 2026, Court Online confirmed that it had received my request for access to the Johannesburg High Court file in Shadrack Mongo Sibiya v The State, case A2026-275886. Sibiya, a former deputy national police commissioner, is appealing the Randburg Magistrate’s Court’s refusal of bail on 20 October.
See the SABC News report on the appeal
I forwarded the acknowledgement to Court Online support twice on 6 November. On 10 November, I wrote to Marelize Potgieter at the OCJ. I told her that I had managed to obtain documents through Court Online only twice since the system came into operation. Potgieter copied in the court administration team, saying it would be able to assist. The following morning I wrote again. I still had no access.
Wilna Lambley, the OCJ’s acting deputy director-general for court administration services, replied on 11 November. “It should be noted that only parties to the proceedings are given access to CourtOnline,” she wrote.
I sent her the Gauteng Division’s Revised Consolidated Practice Directive 1 of 2024, as amended on 12 June 2024, and drew her attention to paragraph 2.3. I also raised my concern about cash for access. The emails about Sibiya’s file contain no request for payment.
What the directive says
Paragraph 2.3 begins with a reminder that “court files are public documents”. It says that anyone requesting access to an electronic court file may be refused only in special circumstances, giving matters involving a minor or state security as examples. It then tells journalists how to submit a request on Court Online. When the portal asks them to identify with a party, they should select the applicant as a matter of routine. The directive says this is for uniformity and to avoid any inference of bias. The judiciary’s own Court Online guidance also lists journalistic interest as a reason a person can give when applying for access.
See Practice directive, p. 6 and Court Online guidance
Lambley replied on 12 November. She said the OCJ recognised open justice as a fundamental principle, but that filing a document did not necessarily make it immediately accessible to the public. She said the appeal was pending and that questions of access could require a judicial decision. She referred me to section 18 of the same directive. She also rejected as unfounded the suggestion I had raised in my email that improper considerations might have influenced the response.
Section 18 deals mainly with media access to court hearings. Paragraph 18.7 expressly deals with records. It allows journalists to request access to records filed on CaseLines or by other electronic means through the presiding judge’s secretary. The secretary enables access under the judge’s direction, subject to the system’s restrictions and protocols. Paragraph 2.3 sets out the presumption of access and tells journalists how to apply through Court Online. Paragraph 18.7 provides a route through the judge’s office. Lambley’s reply left unexplained how the OCJ applies those two provisions to a request already lodged through the portal.
See Practice directive, pp. 33–34
From paper files to Court Online
Cash for access to court files has been reported in more than one South African court. In 2013, I reported on a Johannesburg High Court tout who demanded cash to retrieve a file. In 2025, Daily Maverick reported on an anonymous complaint alleging that Mthatha High Court officials demanded payments to retrieve files and expedite other court services. My encounter with the “motivation fee” concerned a file that could only be accessed electronically. For that file, there was no paper copy I could ask to inspect at the counter. Where the electronic file is the only copy available to a requester, the way a court handles access determines whether the public can scrutinise the record. If cash can move one request up the queue, timely access depends in part on who can pay.
See Moneyweb’s Johannesburg investigation and Ray Hartle’s Daily Maverick’s Mthatha report
What happened to the request?
In SANRAL, the court said restrictions should be considered case by case. That matters here because the question is what, if anything, needs protection in this particular file. The underlying charges include an allegation involving a minor, one of the circumstances contemplated by paragraph 2.3. Lambley’s reply did not invoke that exception, identify any judicial direction restricting access, or say whether my request had been referred to a judge.
See the Associated Press reporting on the underlying case
By the end of the exchange on 12 November, the only thing Court Online had confirmed was that my request had been submitted. A week after that acknowledgement, I still had no access to the file and no indication of who would decide whether I could see it. For a reporter trying to follow a pending appeal, open justice depends on whether an access request reaches someone who can decide it while the case is still before the court.
CONCERNING ATTITUDE FROM COURT STAFF
Veteran journalist Tony Beamish approached the High Court for access to Shadrack Sibiya’s bail appeal file.
He writes about the attitude of court staff in the article above. This is despite the Supreme Court of Appeal making it clear in City of Cape Town v SANRAL [2015] ZASCA 58 that court records by default should be open to the public in the interests of open justice.
Even more disturbing, Tony describes how he previously sought a file in another matter and the court staff described a cash payment that would move the request up the queue. They called it a “motivation fee”.
They said there was nothing illegal or corrupt about it. In their telling, it was payment for faster service, something akin to a public-private partnership. These justice department employees seem to forget that they are public servants whose comfortable pay packages are paid for by us taxpayers. Those court files are not their property. They are public records and everything in their production and storage has been paid for by us taxpayers.
These civil servants at the justice department need a serious reset of attitude back to the values of Batho Pele.
PS – I had a similar experience years ago. We were scolded and reprimanded by several senior OCJ officials because we wanted access to heads of argument to add them to online judgments. These officials were dismissive of the SCA judgment in the SANRAL matter and implied that we were doing something improper. The analogy was used of us wanting the keys for the shed in which someone’s property was kept safe. How did advocates’ heads of argument become the sole property of the OCJ? It was totally lost on these officials the value to lawyers, judges and law students of being able to read the heads alongside the judgment.